This website requires JavaScript.

Persecution? VP Defense Shows Corona Trial Videos

Persecution? VP Defense Shows Corona Trial Videos

The defense panel tried to raise the issue of political persecution against Vice President Sara Duterte as her Senate impeachment trial resumed on Thursday, Nov. 19.

Aside from presenting Rainer dela Fuente, a former financial investigator of the Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) secretariat as witness, the defense showed video clips of the late Supreme Court chief justice Renato Corona and the late Miriam Defensor-Santiago, who was a senator-judge during Corona’s impeachment trial in 2012. The defense also showed a video of former president Rodrigo Duterte.

Prosecution lawyer and Akbayan party-list Rep. Chel Diokno questioned the relevance of showing videos of Corona during the impeachment hearing against the Vice President, to which defense counsel Mark Vinluan said, “We already learned at this point that the impeachment is not a purely a legal proceeding (but) there is a political aspect.”

As seen in the video, Corona, in his testimony, mentioned about the use of government agencies, such as the AMLC and the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) that conducted investigations against him and members of his family, tainting his reputation and honor.

On one hand, Defensor-Santiago was seen in a video clip questioning the prosecution in the Corona trial, asking if they withdrew the articles of impeachment to conduct a trial by publicity.

Paolo Panelo, spokesperson for the Vice President, said that it was important to be reminded of what happened during the impeachment trial of Corona, who was accused of accumulating unexplained wealth. While he was impeached by the Senate impeachment court, the Sandiganbayan dismissed the forfeiture case against him.

“I think the defense team wanted to show that the AMLC records could be used for political persecution because in the case of Corona, the people thought that he had unexplained wealth but when it went through the correct process, which is to file a legal case before the Sandiganbayan, it showed that he had no hidden wealth,” Panelo said.

He said the Vice President has endured the same experience, when the entire government force was reportedly used against her not only at the impeachment trial but with allegations hurled against her outside of the impeachment court.

“Every day, she was being accused of something new. They are weaponizing government institutions against her,” Panelo said, adding that this is being done using government resources and taxpayers’ money.

Early in the impeachment case against Duterte, the prosecution, after presenting their witnesses and evidence, withdrew Article 1 (confidential funds) and Article 4 (grave threats) while Article 3 (bribery) was dropped without presenting any evidence or witness.

Duterte did not have the opportunity to present her defense to the dropped or withdrawn Articles of Impeachment.

Meanwhile, in the video of former president Duterte, the father of the Vice President, he was asked by a reporter about a possible filing of impeachment complaint against then vice president Leni Robredo.

But the former president said the country just finished an election aid, “Guys, land say off. Just stop it. Do other things but do not tinker with the structure of government. I will not countenance it. She (Robredo) was elected so why do you have, just because she keeps on harping and harping on me? Let it be. This is democracy, freedom of speech. There are no overt acts.”

Senator-judges were irked by the defense team’s move to present videos of deceased public officials to tell the court how the ongoing impeachment trial has become a trial by publicity.

Defensor-Santiago was shown berating the 2011 House prosecution panel’s move to withdraw five of the eight impeachment articles against Corona and taking the court for a ride in their publicity trial.

Corona’s video showed him turning emotional on the witness stand about how his trial had caused a “chilling effect” on the judiciary.

“That is a different case. This is a different case. This is a different set of senators. I really do not understand. Why are we watching this?” Sen. Erwin Tulfo said.

Sen. Risa Hontiveros called it unfair to bring up the videos of two public officials who have departed, and that of the former president, who is not here.

House prosecution has considered the case of the defense “dead” after the latter presented videos of two deceased public officials instead of addressing Duterte’s alleged P818-million unexplained wealth.

Defense panel spokesperson Michael Poa said they expect five to six more witnesses, which would be their last batch of witnesses, by December. – With Marc Jayson Cayabyab, Daphne Galvez, Evelyn Macairan